Skip to content

Does ‘New Media’ Bring New Attitudes Toward Women’s Sports?

09/24/2009
by

hardin-webMarie Hardin, Ph.D., is the associate director for research in the John Curley Center for Sports Journalism at Penn State University and will be a panelist for the Tucker Center Distinguished Lecture Series on social media and women’s sport.


Does ‘new media’ bring new attitudes toward women’s sports?

Unfortunately, no. But we have new tools and platforms for our advocacy.

Social media, such as blogs, Twitter, Facebook, have changed the way sports news and commentary is presented and consumed by fans. The “transmission model” for sports coverage, where media professionals were the gatekeepers for what did (and did not) get ink or airtime, has disintegrated. Coverage and commentary is now much more user-driven and community-oriented.

These changes have, for women’s sports advocates, sparked hope that female athletes and sports would finally receive the “fair shake” they deserve after a long history of marginalization. Institutional media in every form have always unfairly allocated the lion’s share of coverage to men’s sports.  Many advocates believed that primary reasons for this were that men dominated the production ranks in print and broadcast media and in advertising (and favored men’s sports). The fact that gatekeepers for traditional media have been overwhelmingly male meant female athletes received little-to-no media attention.

Social media and the Internet, however, have eroded the institutional barriers traditionally blamed for putting women on the sidelines. Now, anyone (male or female) can become a journalist with a step as simple as starting a blog. Thanks to social networking, fans of women’s sports can find one another, join forces, and promote their favorite athletes and teams. With new media, then, it could be argued that many the barriers to fair, equitable and positive attention to women’s sports have come down.

So, why, then, is the sports blogosphere generally giving us more of the same – and worse? The overwhelming majority of sports commentary on the most popular blogs continues to be focused on male athletes at the college and professional levels. When attention is diverted to female athletes or sports-related personalities (such as female sports reporters), it is often belittling and sexist and is sometimes cruel.

Thus, it seems that although the technology has presented liberating possibilities for women’s sports, those possibilities aren’t being met. Instead, the new media platforms are replicating the discrimination and bias that has always been a part of old-media framing of women’s sports.

Based on surveys by the John Curley Center for Sports Journalism at Penn State, the similarities in demographics and attitudes between traditional journalists and those who write the most popular sports blogs are striking. For instance, our demographic research indicates that about 11 percent of the personnel in U.S. sports departments are women (and that number has likely slipped in past months). A survey of independent sports bloggers shows roughly the same imbalance: Only one in 10 is a woman.

We’ve also asked bloggers and journalists what they think about coverage of women’s sports and about Title IX. Again, they are remarkably similar. For instance, when we asked sports journalists whether they believed women’s sports should receive more attention in the media, most said no. More bloggers (about half) told us they thought female athletes should get more coverage, but most also told us they thought women’s sports could never have the same appeal as men’s.

We then asked reporters and bloggers whether they believed “Title IX has hurt men’s sports,” a myth about the law that reinforces negative attitudes toward female athletes. Again, almost half of respondents in both groups agreed (indicating a fundamental misunderstanding of the law’s impact). About one-third of journalists and one-fourth of bloggers went so far as to say they thought the law should be changed.

All of these attitudes affect the ways bloggers and journalists present — or don’t — women’s sports. The evidence of these attitudes is as easy to find as the first or second click into sites such as SBNation.com, a host to hundreds of blogs.

Of course, this is not to say that fans of women’s sports haven’t been able to find coverage and community through new media. They have. But the fact remains that the vast majority of social networking around sports is dedicated to men and male athletes, and the blogosphere is – by bloggers’ own admission – “quite sexist.”

Thus, new media mimics old. Even with the bells and whistles that accompany the technology, it’s familiar terrain. Thus, our work remains. We must continue to connect to educate, to advocate, to promote, and to protect the rights of girls and women to pursue sports.

Advertisements
5 Comments leave one →
  1. 10/02/2009 6:09 pm

    Marie,

    Thanks for this great analysis of the women’s sports blogosphere.

    I have a couple of thoughts on it…

    First, ust to extend your point about how “the liberating possibilities for women’s sports aren’t being met”, I think a major reason for the continued dominance of men’s sports on the web is that ultimately, the big networks like ESPN/FoxSports/CBSsportslines still dominate the online world as they do the offline world and people look to them as the trusted sources. While there are bloggers out there, the trend is that they get considerably less and considerably more diffuse traffic than the major sites, whether it be politics or sports.

    Second, to your point about SB Nation, I do want to say that it did recently launch its first dedicated women’s sports blog covering women’s basketball (www.SwishAppeal.com) and is considering launching another blog with an emphasis on female athletes.

    Obviously, 1 out of 213 blogs (or 2 out of 214) is not “liberation”… but it is something they are aware of and trying to address…and I think integrating women’s sports into a network that gets that much traffic is an important step in improving coverage…

  2. monica permalink
    11/05/2009 2:06 am

    I am a beneficiary of Title IX, so I say this with muffled conviction. Anyone who claims Title IX discriminates against men is half right…not discrimination by sex but by sport. My little brother was the 2nd best wrestler in the state of Texas growing up, spent as much time training as I did in my sport yet he got zero scholarship offers and I got plenty. The flaw is not with Title IX in and of itself, but in which piece of the “men’s pie” got cut out to make the womens of equal portion. Colleges give their share of mens funding and opportunities to those sports that bring in money, mostly football, then basketball and baseball. If I worked for the USOC, I would be very upset. Heres an interesting question. How many male athletes who were recipients of full rides to college ended up representing our country in the Olympics? Compare that number to women and I’ll bet chicks rule that stat. So what’s the implication and why should we care? Well, because it essentially means we are sacrificing the growth of sport and sports for money. Title IX was groundbreaking because it transcended this, but things are far from equal. I can’t help but feel sorry for my little brother, who ended up at a state school and is still paying off his college. Then I get even more irked when I think about the football players I went to school with who constantly ditched class, cheated their way through and didn’t seem to appreciate the fullness of their ride.

Trackbacks

  1. Marie Hardin’s article- fantastic! « Media Coverage of Female Sports
  2. Media Coverage of Female Sports « Media Coverage of Female Sports
  3. Traditional vs. new media – Will women’s sports ever get equal coverage?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: